Skip to content
EUID Audit service & seal, Home
Get your website audited

This translation has not been editorially reviewed yet. The German version is authoritative. Deutsche Fassung

CO₂ & EmpCo

When is “40 % less CO₂” on a website sufficiently substantiated?

“40 % less CO2” convinces, because it sounds concrete. A comparison that cannot be proven is misleading (§ 5 UWG in Germany, § 2 UWG in Austria); Since 27. Both laws explicitly mention environmental features as essential features. A comparison is taken, if it says what you compare with, how was measured and from which year the numbers are. In the same sentence, the test seeks a reference to the basis: a standard, the word “measured”, a method, a study or a source with “loud”. If each of these indications is missing, she reports the comparison; whether reference value and year are included, a person looks.

Which regulations govern an environmental comparison

An environmental comparison is an indication of an essential characteristic. According to § 5 Abs. 2 UWG in Germany is a misleading act if it contains untrue or otherwise deceptive information about the essential characteristics of a good or service; Since the amendment, No. 1 explicitly mentions the ecological or social characteristics. In Austria, the rule is in § 2 UWG. If the comparison makes a competitor or his offer recognizable, he is comparative advertising: According to § 6 Abs. 2 UWG he must then compare goods or services for the same need and objectively refer to essential, relevant, verifiable and typical characteristics or the price. For comparison services, i.e. portals that compare products of others according to environmental characteristics, comparison method, compared products including providers and the update are expressly considered as essential information (Art. 7 para.). 7 of the Directive, § 5b para 3a UWG.

A percentage value without reference makes the reader guess

By “less than” every reader asks: as what? If the answer is missing, he uses his own comparison, possibly the cheapest: less than all other providers. A comparison with your own predecessor model can be correct and still be understood as such. A second case is set out in the annex to the directive, point 10a: it is deemed to be unfair under all circumstances to present requirements which, by law, apply to all products in a category as being specific to one's own offer. Anyone who emphasizes that his device meets a requirement that every device of this type must comply with, compares with the minimum that every competitor also meets.

A proven comparison applies the same in each document

A comparison with the subject matter, method and year is an indication that you can use in the offer, data sheet, tender and on the website, because each recipient can calculate it. If a buyer asks for the calculation, send the document to which the sentence refers. The basis also forces a conscious choice: a predecessor model from ten years ago gives a large number, the current average of the industry tells the customer more about his choice today. What choice you made, the reader sees when it is in the sentence.

What the check reads as a comparison

A comparison is a percentage with “less” or “more” before CO₂, emissions, energy, electricity, plastic or water, or a word such as “more eco-friendly”, “more sustainable” or “more climate-friendly” with “than”. A standard such as ISO 14067, the statement “measured”, a method, a study or a source with “according to” count as a basis. If that is missing from the sentence, there is a note to look into.

What a complete basis contains

The object of comparison: the previous model, the industry average or a named product. The method: a standard, a calculation model or a measurement. The year of the data and, if the figure comes from outside, the source. If the basis is on a separate page, a link belongs in the sentence with the comparison.

Examples

Energy comparison

Not met
Unsere Heizung verbraucht 40 % weniger CO₂.
Passes
Unsere Heizung verursacht 40 % weniger CO₂ als das Vorgängermodell von 2022, berechnet nach ISO 14067.
  • Search your website for percentages next to CO₂, energy or emissions and for words such as “more eco-friendly than”.
  • In each of these sentences, add what is compared with, by which method and from which year.
  • If there is no reliable basis, delete the comparison and state the absolute value with a date.
  • In addition to the percentage, name the two absolute values, for example in kilograms of CO2 per unit. The reader then sees how big the difference really is.
  • Keep the calculation in a document with date: assumptions, data sources and system boundary, for example with or without transport. If the product changes, recalculate and adjust the sentence.
  • Compare the same to the same: same function, same duration of use, same amount. One liter of concentrate against one liter of finished solution gives an oblique comparison.
  • Apply a percentage value from a supplier’s brochure only to his calculation, and link the datasheet to the date from which the number came.

Deutsche Fassung dieser Seite

  • Seal Digitale Barrierefreiheit
  • Seal Daten & Recht
  • Seal Technische Qualität
  • Seal Digital Excellence
  • Seal Cyberversicherung

Audited. For a better digital future.euid.com

When is “40 % less CO₂” on a website sufficiently substantiated? · euid.com