Skip to content
EUID Audit service & seal, Home
Get your website audited

This translation has not been editorially reviewed yet. The German version is authoritative. Deutsche Fassung

SEO

Why does Google choose a different canonical page than the specified one?

Google chooses a different canonical page if your site’s signals contradict each other or if the specified address shows a different content than the page itself. Your canonical note, the line with the authoritative address, is a strong clue to Google, not an instruction. In Search Console, Google’s free reporting tool, the page then comes under a reason that starts with “duplicate” and goes on to say “Google has designated a page other than the user as a canonical page”. This is not a penalty: the page is classified as a duplicate of another, and the other appears in the search result.

What the message says

The message appears in the page indexing report in the group "Not Indexed". Google’s help explains it this way: The address has been marked as a canonical page, but Google estimates that another page is more suitable, and Google has indexed it instead. In addition, there is a related message: "Duplicate" with the addition "not set by the user as canonical". It appears when a page has no note and Google itself has chosen an authoritative version. Google writes: "This is not a mistake, but quite intentional", because Google does not deliver duplicate pages. After Google’s introduction to search engine optimization, duplicate content on its own website is not a breach of the spam guidelines.

What makes Google the most important page

Google calls what goes into the choice: whether a page comes over https or http, where redirects lead, which address is in the sitemap, the address list for search engines, and what the canonical note says. In addition, there are the internal links: Google advises to always link the relevant address within the website. Typical contradictions are quickly found. The note indicates the address with www, the menu links the version without. The sitemap lists the old http address. A forwarding shall take place in the opposite direction of the note. Or the note points to a page with a different content, for example from page 2 of a list on page 1; according to RFC 6596, the technical description of the note, the target must have the same content or contain it completely.

Same language for several countries

A common case for companies in German-speaking countries: The same German texts are available under one address for Austria and one for Germany. For Google, these are duplicates, and it chooses one of the two as authoritative. Google’s error help recommends hreflang information for such country versions; These are lines in the source code that say which version applies to which country. This allows the appropriate version to appear for searchers in the respective country.

  • In Search Console, open the URL verification tool and enter the affected address. Compare the lines "canonical URL specified by the user" and "canonical URL selected by Google".
  • If Google’s choice is the version you want anyway, such as the https address, have the note switched to this address. Then they both say the same thing.
  • If Google’s choice is wrong, have redirection, sitemap, internal links and note brought to the same address.
  • If the note points to an address you do not know, ask the agency. Google’s error help cites as causes a wrongly set editorial system, an error with the hoster and injected code.

More on this topic

Deutsche Fassung dieser Seite

  • Seal Digitale Barrierefreiheit
  • Seal Daten & Recht
  • Seal Technische Qualität
  • Seal Digital Excellence
  • Seal Cyberversicherung

Audited. For a better digital future.euid.com

Why does Google choose a different canonical page than the specified one? · euid.com