This translation has not been editorially reviewed yet. The German version is authoritative. Deutsche Fassung
Accessibility
What protects a form without captcha?
A form can be protected without captcha: with a hidden bait field that only programs fill, with a spam filter that evaluates the content, and with limited attempts when logging in. A captcha is a puzzle that is supposed to distinguish people and program, such as distorted signs or images with traffic lights. A working group of the W3C advises in its 2021 note to demand visitors only as far as protection requires: If a bait field is sufficient, it remains so until attacks show otherwise.
The Köderfeld intercepts programs and remains invisible to visitors
A bait field (English honeypot) is an additional input field that is in the code and hidden on the page. People leave it empty because they don’t see it. Programs that fill in each field betray themselves. If there is something in it when sending, the server discards the message. According to the W3C note, this is easily implemented; Drupal and several WordPress extensions bring it along. Make sure that the keyboard and read-out program also pass the field.
A spam filter evaluates the message and the visitor does not notice
Spam filters check words, patterns and the frequency of submissions. According to the W3C note, well-set systems achieve results such as a classic image captcha and take the task away from the visitor. Check the sorted out messages regularly: A real request, which the filter incorrectly ranks, does not reach anyone else.
When registering, limit the failed attempts per account
Programs that try through passwords slow down an upper limit for failed attempts. The security project OWASP advises to keep the counter at the account and not at the IP address, because attacks come from many addresses. The W3C also counts a puzzle that only appears sometimes to criterion 3.3.8. If it requires more than the recognition of objects, a way without task must remain open, such as a login link by e-mail.
In the contact form, a different rule applies than when registering
Criterion 3.3.8 covers the notification. For a captcha in the contact form, criterion 1.1.1 applies: A text indicates the purpose of the image, and a second version speaks to a different sense, such as hearing. An image alone does not meet the requirement.
Invisible inspection services save the puzzle and collect data
Services like Google’s reCAPTCHA v3 rate visitors in the background and deliver value without any task. The W3C note prefers such methods for accessibility and mentions the hooks. If the value is unclear, you decide what happens; A puzzle as a relapse brings back the hurdle. And who installs it, according to the note, exposes its visitors to an extensive collection of personal data. Clarify this before installation with your data protection advice.
Every puzzle is a place where someone gives up
Researchers at the University of California, Irvine, rate any task cancelled due to a captchas as a possible loss to the website, whether purchase or account opening. In their paid online study, 18 to 45 percent of participants gave up after the first captcha, depending on the framework and pay. This number does not come from a shop. The mechanics are the same: the visitor wanted to ask a question and should first click on traffic lights.
Programs solve distorted signs faster and safer than humans
The same study had 1,400 people solve captchas and compares the values of published results of programs. With distorted signs, people needed 9 to 15 seconds and were right in 50 to 84 percent of cases. Programs took less than one second and were 99.8 percent right. Researchers attribute this to advances in image recognition and machine learning. The W3C note concludes: As protection, a captcha works less and less.
Examples
Köderfeld in the contact form
<img src="captcha.php" alt="Sicherheitscode">
<input name="code"><div hidden>
<label for="website">Bitte leer lassen</label>
<input id="website" name="website" autocomplete="off">
</div>The hidden attribute hides the field from the eyes, keyboard and read-out program. The server discards any message in which it is filled.
- Ask your agency to include a bait field in the contact form and watch the incoming messages before the captcha goes away.
- What makes a sign-in process on a website accessible?An accessible sign-in process requires no memory or puzzle task: password managers and pasting remain allowed. That's what WCAG criterion 3.3.8 governs.
- Is it worth a passkey for your own website?A passkey replaces the password with a key on the customer’s device. What he brings to your customer accounts and what happens when the phone is lost.




