This translation has not been editorially reviewed yet. The German version is authoritative. Deutsche Fassung
Accessibility
Newsletter window: when does it bother visitors and Google?
A newsletter window interferes as soon as it obscures the content before the visitor had any of it. This is exactly the pattern described by the Nielsen Norman Group from its user tests, and Google advises against covering the entire page in its documentation. The same question can be asked elsewhere: as a login field at the end of an article or as a narrow banner that can be clicked away.
Before the first sentence, no one knows your offer
Anna Kaley of the Nielsen Norman Group recorded in 2019, which annoys test subjects with insertions. Newsletter windows that block the text immediately after opening an article are part of this. One participant said it annoyed him if something like this appeared before he even did anything on the site. Their advice follows the principle of reciprocity: first offer value, then demand something. In addition, people close such windows hastily because they do not expect anything good from it. Your text in the window will remain unread.
Google advises banners that occupy little space
Google writes in its documentation: Do not cover the whole page, and use banners that occupy only a small part of the screen. Intrusive windows make it difficult for search engines to understand the content and can worsen visibility in search. Since 10 January 2017, pages with content that is difficult to access when viewed from mobile search can be ranked worse; Google calls this one of hundreds of signals. Excluded are insertions for legal obligation such as cookie notice and age check, login window for non-public content and banners of a reasonable size, which can be easily closed.
A window that opens itself requires focus guidance
The W3C describes how a window that locks the side behind it guides the keyboard focus, i.e. the marked location: when opened in, the tab key remains in the window, when closed. With a window that opens by itself, there is no triggering element, so the focus belongs back to where the visitor was. If this guidance is missing, the read-out program continues to read the text behind it. Level AAA Criterion 2.2.4 goes one step further: visitors can postpone the interruption or stop it altogether.
Your statistics shows the registrations, the losses are missing there
A window brings logins, and that shows your statistics immediately. Anyone who walks for the window does not appear there. Therefore, compare a few weeks with and a few weeks without windows, counting requests and purchases. A figure on the effect on sales does not mention any of the sources listed here.
Examples
Window when loading the side
window.addEventListener('load', zeigeNewsletterFenster);<article>…</article>
<aside>
<h2>Neue Artikel per Mail</h2>
<form>…</form>
</aside>The application is at the end of the article. Anyone who has read it knows what the newsletter brings.
- Place the login field at the end of an item or on the thank you page after an order.
- Ask the question in a narrow banner that closes with one click and remains closed.
- Do not show visitors coming from Google Search a window on the entry page.
- Withhold any overlay as long as someone works in the checkout or form.




